"Mz. Geller" is Pamela Geller, the editor of the blog Atlas Shrugs and president of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI) as well as Stop Islamization of America (SIOA). She is a fierce defender of free speech, and sponsored a "Muhammad Art Exhibit and Contest" in Garland, Texas this month. As you may have heard, two Islamist gunmen, apparently furious that such an event could be allowed to take place, stormed the venue with high-powered firearms, but were both shot dead by an off-duty policeman who'd been hired for security.
The aftermath has been controversial, with apologists who clearly don't understand our First Amendment - people Salman Rushdie calls "the but brigade" - trying to blame the victim of the attack rather than the gunmen. "Yes, we believe in freedom of speech, but..."
There's no "but." You either believe in freedom of speech or you don't. Steve Artley, the Gazett Packet's editorial cartoonist, doesn't.
And so I've sent the following letter to his editor:
That's a pretty neat trick Steve Artley, your editorial cartoonist, pulled off last week - pretending to defend free speech while attacking one of its most vigorous defenders.
Let's see if they publish it.The point of free speech seems to be lost on Mr. Artley. Speech that offends no one need not be defended; no one ever got in trouble for saying, "Have a nice day." Offensive speech is the speech that needs to be defended - the only speech that needs to be defended.Defended from whom?Defended from those who would kill you merely for offending them by expressing it.If you dread to open your mouth for fear that someone will kill you for it, you have made him your master. If he can forbid you to draw pictures on pain of death, he can forbid you to worship the God you choose, forbid you to not worship God, forbid you to marry whom you choose, forbid you to disobey your husband - the list is endless. Far worse than the "heckler's veto" over your speech, he wields the murderer's veto.How do you stand up to such a person? There is only one way: to do exactly that which he expressly forbids. When I was a teenager, African-Americans were forbidden to eat at lunch counters in some department stores. How did they demand their rights? By sitting down at those lunch counters. They were forbidden to sit in certain seats on public buses. How did they resist? By sitting in those forbidden seats. They were forbidden to march from Selma, Alabama to petition for their basic voting rights as Americans. How did they resist? By marching.When someone threatens you with violence for daring to exercise your rights, he determines the manner of your defiance - doing exactly that which he forbids. If he can forbid you to exercise that right, you must defy him, or else you have lost that right; you have made the murderer your master, and it's just a matter of time before he finds more things to forbid you on pain of death.It's easy to say you believe in free speech - as long as it doesn't cost you anything. Susan Geller has done what any American who truly believes in free speech must do - defy the threats. If the editors of the Gazette Packet also believe in the value of free speech, they will publish the drawing of Muhammad that won her contest. The artist, Bosch Fawstin, has granted permission on his blog and twitter feed to those who wish to publish it - http://fawstin.blogspot.com/ and @BoschFawstin.If you don’t really believe in free speech, or if you're afraid to exercise your right, then you'll ignore that challenge. After all, publishing a cartoon portraying a middle-aged Jewish woman as a sewer-dweller is a lot safer than publishing a picture of Muhammad.
Update: Two weeks later, they haven't printed my letter. I suppose I should be surprised.
President
of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI) and Stop Islamization
of America (SIOA). - See more at:
http://pamelageller.com/about/#sthash.IO45bDvF.dpuf
President of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI) and Stop
Islamization of America (SIOA). - See more at:
http://pamelageller.com/about/#sthash.IO45bDvF.dpuf
President of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI) and Stop
Islamization of America (SIOA). - See more at:
http://pamelageller.com/about/#sthash.IO45bDvF.dpuf
President of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI) and Stop
Islamization of America (SIOA). - See more at:
http://pamelageller.com/about/#sthash.IO45bDvF.dpuf
President of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI) and Stop
Islamization of America (SIOA). - See more at:
http://pamelageller.com/about/#sthash.IO45bDvF.dpuf
President of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI) and Stop
Islamization of America (SIOA). - See more at:
http://pamelageller.com/about/#sthash.IO45bDvF.dpuf
President of the American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI) and Stop
Islamization of America (SIOA). - See more at:
http://pamelageller.com/about/#sthash.IO45bDvF.dpuf